Climate movement needs bullying and harassment referee, says Tubiana

The head of the European Climate Foundation said the failure to respond to previous cases that led to harm was ‘heartbreaking’

European Climate Foundation chief Laurence Tubiana at a meeting of EU environment minnisters in 2017 (Photo: Estonian EU Presidency)


The head of an influential funding body is backing the establishment of an independent “referee” for bullying and harassment complaints in the climate movement.

Laurence Tubiana, who leads the European Climate Foundation (ECF), told Climate Home News a “safe space outside all the organisations” was needed for victims of abusive behaviour to raise concerns.

She was responding to revelations that Climate Action Network International (Can-I) had lapsed in its duty of care to staff. The network’s boss of six years, Wael Hmaidan, was fired in January after a workplace investigation corroborated allegations of sexual harassment and bullying against him. An investigation by CHN, released last week, found the board had ignored warning signs, before and after the suicide of Holly Borday, a former staffer.

Investigation: NGO ignored warnings about bullying boss, before and after tragedy

Tubiana described it as “heartbreaking… that we [the climate movement] did not react with the necessary speed”. Many small NGOs lack the capacity or independent channels to handle such matters appropriately, she said.

ECF staff are in preliminary discussions with partner organisations about appointing an ombudsman to advise on and investigate complaints from organisations across the international climate movement. This could be a retired lawyer or judge, Tubiana suggested.

Her foundation funds a broad range of climate change think tanks and campaign groups, including Can-I and several of its member organisations. Climate Home News also receives some assistance from the foundation.

We need your help… Climate Home News is an independent news outlet dedicated to the most important global stories. If you can spare even a few dollars each month, it would make a huge difference to us. Our Patreon account is a safe and easy way to support our work.

The funder turned over €34 million ($38m) in 2017, according to its latest financial statement. Before joining as chief executive, Tubiana played a central role in French diplomacy leading to the 2015 Paris Agreement.

UN sustainable energy chief Rachel Kyte has also commented on lessons from the Can-I story, tweeting it was “critical” for the non-profit sector to “ensure professional standards of management and governance”.

The workplace investigation into Hmaidan identified “troubling” systemic issues at Can-I and recommended a range of reforms. These included the appointment of an outside HR expert to act as a contact point for staff.

A spokesperson for the Can-I board said they were reviewing the options and had set up several committees to address the concerns raised.

If you would like to contact Climate Home News securely, we recommend setting up a free, encrypted ProtonMail account here and emailing [email protected].

Republish this article

Read more on: Activism and campaigning | Climate justice | Climate politics |