EU committee shelves climate concerns to open US trade talks

Amid US threats to slap import tariffs on European cars, the EU is wavering on its commitment to uphold the Paris Agreement through trade negotiations

The EU is mulling two trade deals with the US, despite climate concerns (Pic: NOAA/Captain Albert E. Theberge)


The EU is preparing to negotiate two trade agreements with the US, contrary to pledges to only strike deals with countries committed to the Paris Agreement.

A committee of the European Parliament on Tuesday endorsed opening talks. Adopted by 21 votes to 17, the resolution by the committee for international trade (INTA) empowers the European Commission to discuss two trade deals, respectively designed to lift tariffs and iron out bureaucratic hurdles between the two blocs. It goes to a full parliamentary vote in mid-March.

The move flies in the face of European moves to integrate trade and climate action. In July 2018, the European Parliament backed a non-binding resolution to “make ratification and implementation of the Paris Agreement a condition for future trade agreements”.

The latest deals with Japan and Mexico made reference to the Paris Agreement. Trade commissioner Cecilia Malmström has asserted that the same applies to ongoing negotiations with South America’s Mercosur bloc.

Amid US threats to slap tariffs on European car imports, however, the committee overruled climate concerns to press ahead with US talks.

Climate news in your inbox? Sign up here

The chair of the committee, Bernd Lang, initially drafted a resolution rejecting the trade talks, citing “deep regret” over “the withdrawal of the US from the ‘Paris Agreement’”. US president Donald Trump has signalled his intent to pull out of the pact.

Lang’s resolution also recalled “that the European Parliament stressed in its resolution on climate diplomacy that the EU should make the ratification and implementation of the ‘Paris Agreement’ a pre-condition to conclude any trade agreement.”

Social Democrats (S&D), the Greens, the European United Left (GUE) and Europe of Freedom and Direct Democracy (EFDD) fought for a strengthened version of the passage on climate, a spokesperson for Green MEP Yannick Jaddot told Climate Home News.

But the new text, pushed by the right-wing group European People’s Party (EPP), the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats (ALDE) and European Conservative and Reformists (ECR), inserts a caveat limiting the Paris condition to “comprehensive trade talks”.

The “recommendations refer to a limited agreement and not a comprehensive free trade agreement; therefore considers that those agreements should represent an exception dictated by specific circumstances and in any case not a precedent for the European Union in future negotiations,” said the amendment, which just about scraped through.

Comment: Trump is wrecking the climate and free trade. Here is a common solution for both

The French treasury has similarly equivocated, despite multiple calls by Emmanuel Macron to weaponize trade in defence of the Paris Agreement. Asked whether the French government intended to counter Brussels’ move to negotiate with the US, Pierre Chabrol, from the Treasury board, said that Macron’s commitments only applied to large trade deals like the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP). “The reach of these two [trade] mandates is more restrained and the situation is different,” he told Mathilde Dupré, a trade analyst for the Paris-based NGO Veblen Institute.

“We are sacrificing a minimal commitment to enforce the Paris Agreement, all of that so that the Germans can continue to sell their big cars in the United States,” Dupré told CHN.

France’s Ministry for the Ecological Transition did not respond immediately to CHN’s question on whether these comments represented the official view of the government.

“It’s just an excuse from the French Treasury in my opinion,” said a source from the European Parliament.

Global issues need global coverage

CHN is dedicated to bringing you the best climate reporting from around the world. It’s a huge job and we need your help.

Through our Patreon account you can give as little or as much as you like to support our work. It’s safe and easy to sign up.

The committee resolution did call for a sustainability impact assessment on the deal, an analysis designed to measure the greenhouse gas effects of liberalizing trade that is compulsory to EU trade agreements, despite the Commission’s efforts to waive it. “They say that we can use the TTIP impact assessment as a basis, but that impact assessment does not include the EU’s Paris commitments,” the parliamentary source said.

More than 62 NGOs called on the European Union to drop trade negotiations with the climate pariah on Monday. Citing unprecedented demonstrations for climate action, including mass school walk-outs for the climate, the authors urged “European decision makers… to listen to the citizens they serve, and show the world that the EU takes the Paris Agreement seriously.”

“Global commitments towards stopping climate change must come before the interests of the EU car lobby. Hard-won standards that protect people and the planet should come before trade deals.”

Republish this article

Read more on: UN climate talks